Debate over Dallas Safari Club auctioning black rhino hunting permit

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

Poaching and lack of conservation have made a subspecies of Africa's black rhino extinct. Photo Credit: Richard Emslie/IUCN

DALLAS, Texas (CNN) — On Saturday night, a group of wealthy hunters will gather inside the Dallas Convention Center to bid on the rare chance to hunt one of the world’s most endangered animals in Namibia.

The Dallas Safari Club is sponsoring the auction and says, as surprising as it might sound, that it’s being done in the name of conservation, to save the threatened black rhinoceros. The permit is expected to fetch between $250,000 and $1 million, and all proceeds will be donated to the Namibian government and will be earmarked for conservation efforts, club officials say.

Animal conservationists estimate there are only about 5,000 black rhinos in the world, 1,700 of which are in the southern Africa nation of Namibia. They are considered a “critically endangered species” by wildlife organizations around the world.

“This is the best way to have the biggest impact on increasing the black rhino population,” said Ben Carter, executive director of the Dallas Safari Club.

Sacrificing one animal for the greater good of the endangered species is a move that critics and animal conservation groups call “perverse” and a “sad joke.”

“They need to be protected, not sold to the highest bidder,” said Jeffrey Flocken of the International Fund for Animal Welfare. “It also sends a dangerous message that these iconic and disappearing animals are worth more as dead trophies to be mounted and hung on a wall in a Texas mansion than living in the wild in Africa.”

Helping or hurting the species?

The auction has sparked a contentious debate over the best way to protect the species that has been brought to the edge of extinction because of man’s appetite for its horn, which is used for daggers, ornaments and, in Asia, traditional medicine.

The Dallas Safari Club said it has received a string of death threats over the auction. The FBI is investigating the threats.

“If a violation of federal law is determined, then additional investigation will take place if necessary,” said Katherine Chaumont, spokeswoman for the Dallas FBI office.

The club obtained the hunting permit from the Namibian government. It’s the first time a black rhino-hunting permit has been auctioned off outside the country.

In recent years, the Namibian Ministry of Environment and Tourism, which oversees the protection of the black rhinos, has allowed three permits a year.

In a letter to the Dallas Safari Club, the Namibian government said, “To hunt a black rhino is not taken lightly by Namibia. … Only old geriatric bulls, which are marginalized in the population and do no contribute to reproduction, are trophy hunted.”

The Dallas Safari Club says the Namibian government will closely monitor the winning bidder’s hunting expedition. The club also insists that by allowing a handful of predetermined rhinos to be killed it’s actually protecting younger, stronger rhinos.

“They’ve already picked out two or three black rhino males that are old, non-breeding males that are not contributing to the population anymore,” Carter said. “We know it’s the right way to do it. We’re relying on science and biologists. This is the best way to support the population of black rhinos.”

But some wildlife conservationists say that argument is dubious.

“It’s a farce to say that this is being done for conservation,” Flocken said. “It’s saying the rarity of this animal is worth more dead than alive.”

Several groups such as IFAW argue it would be better to use these rhinos to promote wildlife viewing and ecotourism by charging people for the experience of seeing one of these ancient beasts up close in the wild.

‘It really is a dilemma’

If an American citizen wins the auction, it’s not clear whether he or she could even bring their trophy back into the United States.

The hunter will need a special permit from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. The last such permit was issued in March 2013, four years after the black rhino was hunted in Namibia, and the service says it hasn’t decided whether it will issue another permit.

“The issuance of that permit (March 2013) does not guarantee the issuance of future permits for the import of black rhino sport-hunted trophies from Namibia or elsewhere,” read a statement.

The biggest threat to these massive beasts is poachers across the African continent. Rhino horns are lucrative on the black market. In Asia, where there are claims it can treat everything from headaches and food poisoning to rheumatism and cancer, horns can fetch up to $60,000 per kilogram, putting its value somewhere between gold and pure cocaine.

In the 1980s, the black rhino population had dwindled to just a few dozen. Conservation efforts have slowly helped beef up herd numbers, but poachers are still a threat.

Marcia Fargnoli, chief executive officer of the Save the Rhino Trust in Namibia, which works with the government to fight poachers, says the group has tried to convince the Namibian government to stop issuing these hunting permits.

But a poor African country like Namibia — where the World Bank estimates the gross per capita income to be less than $6,000 — struggles to fund conservation efforts, Fargnoli says. It’s difficult for the government to ignore the chance to raise so much money so quickly.

“I really believe every rhino counts,” said Fargnoli. “It really is a dilemma. …But I really struggle to say I’m saving rhinos and then say that one can be hunted.”

By Ed Lavandera

CNN’s Jason Morris contributed to this report.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

6 comments

  • Joe

    This is so typical of a group of rich Texans to rationalize what they are doing. If they are really interested in saving the rhino, why don’t they go take some pictures with their family and donate the $250,000. Is it really that much of a thrill to kill a old defenseless animal? This club should be ashamed of themselves and I hope they disband for the good of animals everywhere.

    • Beverly White

      Well said. I have a great idea. Lets have a “shoot the old worthless wealthy Texans” contest. The winner gets to rip the nose off the old wealthy fart, and then shoot him in the a$$. What better way to protect the black rhinos then to get rid of idiots like these.

  • Joe

    If these rich men really want to kill a rhino, we should at least make it a fair match. Put the hunter and the rhino in a field and let them go at it. We could even sell tickets to raise money for the conservation. Of course, there are to be no guns or knives. Man vs rhino. Just make sure it is a rich Texan who has to pay $250,000 for the chance to poach a rhino.

  • Beverly White

    Its greed and stupidity that rules the old wealthy Texans I see. They’re an endangered animal and these fools have no concept of the importance of preserving these creatures. Old and useless bulls ?? They are referring to the Texans , Right ??!!