More victims come forward in large-scale theft case against metro home healthcare worker

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

OLATHE, Kan. -- A woman charged with stealing thousands of dollars worth of jewelry from older folks she was supposed to be taking care of had her first appearance in Johnson County court on Tuesday.

Since FOX 4 first told you about the charges against Aldean “Suzy” Foster last week, detectives say they've discovered more victims. Foster appeared in Johnson County court for the first time since prosecutors charged her with a large-scale theft.

Foster was hired through a company, before she had any criminal charges, to care for seniors in Johnson County, but some of those seniors say she was stealing from them instead.

“I was probably watching television, and I paid no attention to her, I know she was in my bedroom for a very long time, but I didn’t think any more about it until after she had gone,” said one victim who wanted to remain anonymous. “I went in there, and I noticed things were not exactly where I had left them.”

Court documents say victims lost as much as $100,000. After court, FOX 4's Melissa Stern approached Foster for comment.

“Aldean, hi, I’m Melissa with FOX 4, do you have anything to say regarding the theft charges against you?” Stern said.

“She has no comment,” said her attorney.

“No comment,” added Foster.

“Were you stealing from the people you were supposed to be taking care of?” Stern asked Foster, but got no response as they walked off.

“They’re the most vulnerable people, and to take advantage of that trust, it’s a terrible thing,” said Andrew McCarl.

McCarl said he found out Foster was stealing from his mother when police recovered an Overland Park Police Department ring with his dad's name on it from a pawn shop.

“To take something with a family name on it, that’s kind of gutsy. To take a police department ring with a family name on it is fairly incredulous,”McCarl added.

“I’m hoping she doesn’t have that opportunity again,” said the first victim. “She slipped through the cracks, and I paid the price.”

Leawood police say through investigations and speaking with pawn shops, they were able to determine the items stolen from Foster matched several items she had pawned, including items from other jurisdictions. Since then, about a half-dozen more victims have come forward.

“She had been doing this job for quite a while, so it’s unknown how many are out there,” said Detective John Freeman with Leawood police.

Many families say they don’t know the extent of what Foster took from them, as they don’t know every piece of jewelry their loved ones had. Foster will be back in court in May.