After passing Kansas House, bill allowing refusal of service facing opposition in Senate
TOPEKA, Kan. — UPDATE: In a statement sent out by Kansas Senate President Susan Wagle (R-Wichita) on Thursday evening, she believes unless a common ground is found to ease concerns about the bill, it is unlikely to pass the senate. She further stated that after initially reviewing the bill she has grown concerned about its practical impact.
She stated that while a strong majority of her members support laws that define traditional marriage and protect individuals from being forced to violate personal morals, they do not condone discrimination. She does not believe a majority of her caucus will support the bill without the aforementioned common ground.
On Friday, AT&T issued a statement on HB 2453:
“As a major employer and retailer in Kansas, we strongly urge the Kansas Senate to reject HB 2453. This legislation is impossible to implement. The bill promotes discriminatory behavior by businesses against their customers; and, it interferes with AT&T’s management of our employees. It eliminates the use of fair business practices with customers in Kansas. We applaud Senator Wagle’s leadership in pointing out the variety of problems with the bill.”
The bill has moved to the Kansas Senate and is awaiting discussion by the Judiciary Committee.
A bill that would protect religious individuals, groups and businesses who want to refuse services to same-sex couples passed the Republican-dominated House on Wednesday.
House Bill 2453 received a 72-49 vote and has gone to the Senate for its decision.
Such a law may seem unnecessary in a state where same-sex marriage is banned, but some Kansas lawmakers think different.
They want to prevent religious individuals and organizations from getting sued, or otherwise punished, for not providing goods or services to gay couples — or for not recognizing their marriages or committed relationship as valid.
This includes employees of the state.
The law claims to protect the rights of religious people, but gender rights advocates such as Equality Kansas are dismayed.
“Kansans across the state are rightly appalled that legislators are spending their efforts to pass yet another piece of legislation that seeks to enshrine discrimination against gay and lesbian people into law,” state chairwoman Sandra Meade said.
“HB 2453 is a blatant attempt to maintain second-class citizen status for taxpaying gay and lesbian Kansans.”
Despite the blowback, its chances of passing seem pretty good.
Republicans dominate the state’s Senate and Gov. Sam Brownback is a conservative Christian known for taking a public stand against same-sex marriage.
Brownback has already praised the bill in an interview with a local newspaper.
“Americans have constitutional rights, among them the right to exercise their religious beliefs and the right for every human life to be treated with respect and dignity,” he told The Topeka Capital-Journal.
HB 2453 is titled “An act concerning religious freedoms with respect to marriage” and covers many bases.
It reads, in part: “No individual or religious entity shall be required by any governmental entity to do any of the following, if it would be contrary to the sincerely held religious beliefs of the individual or religious entity regarding sex or gender:
“Provide any services, accommodations, advantages, facilities, goods, or privileges; provide counseling, adoption, foster care and other social services; or provide employment or employment benefits, related to, or related to the celebration of, any marriage, domestic partnership, civil union or similar arrangement.”
Anyone who turns away a gay couple not only can’t face a civil suit, but if anyone tries to sue, they could get nailed with the other side’s legal fees.
There are some small concession in the bill to gay couples.
If an employee at a nonreligious or government business refuses to serve a gay or lesbian couple for religious reasons, the manager is obligated to find another employee who will oblige.
It also explicitly says that the law does not authorize discrimination against anyone, including clergy, who performs or supports same-sex unions.
The Kansas bill would seem to buck the trend.
Laws approving same-sex marriage have recently passed in many parts of the United States, bringing the total number of states where it is legal to 17. Add to that the District of Columbia.
Worldwide, 16 other countries (and parts of Mexico) also have laws allowing same-sex marriage and domestic partnerships. Most of the nations are in Europe and South America.
CNN’s Sonya Hamasaki contributed to this report.