Fans waited for it, but it was not legendary

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

(CNN) — In the end, it was always Robin.

That was the big bombshell from Monday night’s final episode of “How I Met Your Mother,” which piled on one surprise after another.

When Ted finally finished the story for his kids, they called him on it: His story wasn’t all about how he met their mother (she was barely in the story), it was about how much he loved Robin.

As many had theorized, the mother of Ted’s children (whose name was Tracy McConnell, by the way), had been dead for years by the time he told his story.

So, in the last of many flash-forwards in this finale, Ted went to the street in front of Robin’s apartment and showed up with that blue French horn, the same one he stole for her in the first episode.

Robin, of course, had long ago divorced Barney — the first big shocker of the night.

Barney, however, we would learn, became a father, and in one of several touching scenes from the episode, finally found the love of his life in baby Ellie.

Marshall and Lily, pregnant with their second child in the present day, went on to have a third, but Lily was heartbroken when Robin decided she couldn’t be as much a part of their gang anymore, due in part to Barney continuing to be, well, Barney around her.

And what about the mother, aka Tracy? We finally did see that moment of the two meeting at that train station, and it was played perfectly by Josh Radnor and the Emmy-worthy Cristin Milioti.

They wouldn’t get married for several years, having postponed their wedding when Tracy got pregnant with their first child.

Ted shared with his kids that he learned he had to love their mother with everything he had in him, through good times and bad, especially during her illness.

Needless to say, the show stayed true to form, as it had in all its nine years, wearing its heart on its sleeve. And if your eyes stayed dry through the entire episode, you’re probably a stronger person than most viewers.

Of course, the big Robin twist didn’t exactly sit well with everyone online (people such as Rocco Horvath @RoccoRacingAMA, who tweeted, “It took me so long to get over the fact Ted and Robin weren’t going to end up together and now this?! Mixed Emotions”), and the finale seems to have split viewers more than any since “Lost.”

Other viewers were more forgiving. “#HIMYM creators stayed true to the story,” tweeted fan John Eisele. “Finale fit the show, even if it is not what I wanted. Can’t stop thinking about it. #HIMYMFinale.”

What do you think? Do you wish Tracy had stayed alive and Ted didn’t ultimately end up with Robin? Or do you think it was a fitting ending? For that matter, what do you think about Barney and Robin splitting up? Let us know in the comments and give yourself a self-five for making it all the way through nine seasons.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


  • Frosty

    Joffrey gets poisoned next season at his wedding, by the Martells. Tyrion gets blamed and sentenced to death. His brother helps him escape, on his way out he kills his father. Can’t be a spoiler if it’s already in a book. Using your logic :-) have a nice day.

    • E

      I see what you’re saying with that, but I’d say the main difference would be that this is a thread for HIMYM and not game of thrones. I agree that probably a spoiler alert tag should have been added, but you cant really compare a thread about HIMYM with writing the next season of a different show on a thread about something totally different.

      Now that I read that though I’m interested to see how closely the series sticks to the books!

  • t.a.

    Ummmm… is it a spoiler?? Don’t you have to choose to read the story to make it a spoiler? If you don’t want to know what happened….DON’T READ THE STORY! That said, I really liked the final episode, however I do believe having the mother die was unnecessary (ooops, spoiler alert)

    • Frost

      It’s not exactly obvious what the article entails with that title. I didn’t come to it browsing the web and clicking on articles, fox4 emails me when a new article is posted. I like to stay in touch with current events. Fans waited for it, but it was not legendary could just as easily have referred to the Diablo 3 expansion etc. It doesn’t clearly state what it’s about, which would be fine if the article didn’t use the very first sentence to reveal a gigantic spoiler, by the time I read that it clicked what it was about. Too late though. If there was any indication what the article was actually about, I obviously wouldn’t have read it. I work 20 hour shifts so I couldn’t watch it on broadcast, I avoided facebook until I could watch the show. It never even dawned on me that this site would so blatantly spoil the series the morning after airing.

      BTW of course you can have spoilers after something airs.

  • Heather Lehman

    I LOVED IT! I have watched EVERY episode and I will say that it turned out good….I just wish that it wasn’t over! I wanna see what ellie looks like later and I want to know if Ted and Robin stay together..but that is the point I suppose…….It WILL be the most missed show since FRIENDS….in my book anyway! FAN FOR LIFE! HIMYM!!!!!!