LOGAN, Utah — A Utah man who pleaded guilty to killing and sexually assaulting his 5-year-old niece was sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole Tuesday during an emotional hearing where the girl’s relatives called him a “monster” who savagely took the life of an innocent child.
Judge Kevin K. Allen scolded Alex Whipple for the “incomprehensible” terror he inflicted on Elizabeth “Lizzy” Shelley, her family and the community.
Lizzy’s disappearance in May triggered a massive search and widespread concern in the picturesque mountain valley community of Logan.
“You will never see the light of day. You will never breathe fresh air again,” Allen said. “What you did was so abhorrent and vile that you must spend the rest of your life in prison.”
The 22-year-old Whipple declined to speak, hung his head and showed no emotion during the hearing.
He pleaded guilty last month to murder, kidnapping and sexual assault as part of an agreement that dismissed charges of obstruction of justice and desecration of a body.
Whipple’s attorney, Shannon Demler, said his client knew he committed a horrible act and was ready accept his punishment. He said Whipple was raised in an “imperfect” family, was physically abused as a child and developed mental health and substance abuse issues while homeless.
Demler asked the judge for a sentence that would give Whipple the chance to get out someday if he was rehabilitated. He said Whipple has seemed like a polite, likable young man in their interactions since the crime.
“Deep inside he has some good,” Demler said. “I know people in this room may not believe that.”
Prosecutors and relatives painted a different picture as a parade of family members came to the podium urging Allen to keep Whipple in prison for life.
“How could someone do this to their own niece?” said Dejay Smith, Lizzy’s uncle. “I would hope to never see a monster like him walk through this community again.”
Then Smith turned around and spoke directly to Whipple.
“There are few things that are more vile than your actions,” Smith said. “You are the worst kind of person humanity has to offer.”
Another uncle, Zachary Black, also spoke directly to Whipple, who sat only a few feet away.
“You are filth,” he said. “I hope you spend the rest of your life in a tiny box.”
Police say Whipple killed Lizzy on May 25, after his sister let him spend the night at the family home. Authorities have said they found the girl’s blood on Whipple’s clothing, and a bloody, broken knife from the family’s kitchen near where the body was hidden.
She was missing for five days before Whipple told police where to find the child’s body — in the woods less than block from her house — after prosecutors agreed not to seek the death penalty.
Relatives remembered Lizzy as a sweet, happy little girl who loved drawing, being outdoors and rainbow-colored butterflies. A poster board with pictures of Lizzy and rainbow-colored butterflies was placed on an easel in the front of the courtroom. A victim advocate who worked with the family brought a pair of rainbow-colored tennis shoes Lizzy was excited to wear to kindergarten.
Cache County Attorney James Swink called Whipple’s crime a “vicious” and “violent” act that made the community feel “a little less safe, a little more vulnerable.”
Lizzy’s mother, Jessica Black, didn’t come to court because she said she couldn’t bear being in the same room as her brother, but she spoke to reporters afterward and released butterflies to remember her daughter.
She called it a difficult day and said it’s been “dark months” since her daughter was killed but thanked the community for their support.
“I would give anything to be reunited with her, to hug her and hold her one more time,” she said, crying. “Our lives will never be the same. We will never forget our sweet girl and the happiness and sunshine she brought us.”